HSU alumnus and Cal Fire official Hugh Scanlon

HSU alumnus and Cal Fire official Hugh Scanlon says sudden oak death will require different tactics and strategies to contain forest fires fueled by dead trees.

HUMBOLDT STATE'S FOCUS on fire science continues to produce key findings of long-term importance to the Redwood Coast region (see "Fire on the Mountain," Humboldt magazine, spring 2009). The most recent studies have found that spreading tree disease could be a dangerous contributor to forest fires.

Research by scientists at HSU and the University of California Cooperative Extension (UCCE) in Eureka indicates that the onset of sudden oak death in North Coast forests poses a worsening fire threat.

The non-native disease, which was discovered in the Bay Area in the mid-1990s, is found in several coastal counties in California, from Monterey to Humboldt. It has infected 10 percent of the at-risk areas in the state.

Sudden oak death thrives in the coastal climate, and has killed hundreds of thousands of tanoaks and true oaks in the last 15 years. Tanoak, which dies quickly from the disease, is one of the most flammable oaks in California. It is also the hottest burning hardwood in North America.

Dense stands of tanoak blanket Humboldt County. Morgan Varner, a Humboldt State professor who specializes in fire behavior, says land and forest management officials are confronting an infestation that is hard to track and contain across the North Coast landscape. It could present major complications under wildfire conditions.

Although only 1 percent of Humboldt County is currently infected, the disease is spreading and many areas are in jeopardy. Portions of the Van Duzen and Mattole River basins are at risk, as are portions of the Kings Range and the Eel, Mad, Klamath, and Trinity River riparian belts. Within affected areas, the disease could eventually remove most if not all tanoaks, causing a potential cascade of ecological effects of unknown magnitude.


Scientists call tanoak one of the most flammable oaks in California and the hottest burning hardwood in North America.

Varner warns that the most tragic potential location would be an area somewhere in the Klamath basin.

"The basin is home to tremendous tanoak forests on the Trinity, Klamath and Salmon Rivers," he notes. These areas are also prone to wildfire, and recent research by Varner and others shows that sudden oak death can be a game-changer when it comes to fuels and fire.

The disease drastically reduces the moisture content of leaves and foliage. Dead trees devoid of moisture pose a high risk of crown fires, which burn with exceptional heat and speed. They can also cause prolonged ecological damage. Owing to their height, crown fires are also more likely than ground blazes to be whipped up by prevailing winds.

The danger is intensified by a specific characteristic of the disease: tanoaks that die from sudden oak death retain their leaves for up to two years. Eventually, these dead leaves drop to the forest floor, adding to the fire threat. It is both a short- and long-term risk, stretching out in phases for as long as 10 years. Tanoak leaves drop, then the branches. Eventually the tree itself topples.

"These unnatural fuel arrangements can lead to fires so intense that you can't combat them with standard, ground- based firefighting tactics," Varner says. "You just have to move back, and let them die down."

This is one of the principal findings of a paper published by Varner and Yana Valachovic, adjunct HSU faculty member and UCCE Forest Advisor, in the journal Forest Ecology and Management (posted at elsvier.com/locate/foreco).

Their second key finding is that fallen tanoaks contribute greatly to fuel loading on the forest floor, and it can take years for those fuels to break down. As Valachovic says, "In this way, the disease creates a hazardous fuels situation that is passed on to firefighters during wildfire—they must combat blazing downed trees, patches of increased winds and fire behavior and other physical and logistical obstacles."

Hugh Scanlon ('88, Forestry) chief of CAL FIRE's Alder Conservation Camp, helped co-author the paper with Valachovic and Varner. He comments, "In many cases, modeled wildfire conditions in sudden oak death-affected forests exceed safety thresholds for handcrews. This can mean more heavy equipment, aircraft use, indirect lines and more area burned with higher intensity."

This is partly because of the deadly link between fire intensity and flame length. As flames grow longer, their intensity increases exponentially. According to Varner, "when a tree crown is on fire, it's not just that the flame is twice as long, it's that the heat intensity is many times greater." Fighting fire by hand under these conditions is neither safe nor feasible.

Heavy rains and consecutive wet springs speed up the spread of sudden oak death. After the wet spring of 2010, pathogen spread in Humboldt County has been more prevalent than in previous, drier years.

The pathogen survives on the branches and leaves of most affected plants and is easily dispersed. Laboratory tests are required for diagnosis because the symptoms of sudden oak death mimic those of other agents, like insects, fungi or bad environmental conditions.